| 2024- David Mitchell | 2023-Darrell W. Fox | ||
| 2022 – Jason Fox | 2021 – Larry Frost | 2020 – Aaron Johnson | 2019 – Darrell W. Fox |
| 2018 – Jason Matthew Fox | 2017 – Richard C. Willyard | 2016 – David Ehrhart | 2015 – Robert Dailey |
| 2014 – Cecil Lorance | 2013 – Richard C. Willyard | 2012 – David Ehrhart | 2011 – Scott Oldham |
| 2010 – David Mitchell | 2009 – Robert Rains | 2008 – William Michael Hess | 2007 – Philip Wickliff |
| 2006 – James H. Fairchild | 2005 – Gene Clark | 2004 – Ned Cline | 2003 – Gene Clark |
| 2002 – Paul Duane Matthews | 2001 – Ned Cline | 2000 – Kenneth Groce | 1999 – Tim Ogborne |
| 1998 – Paul Duane Matthews | 1997 – Larry Frost | 1996 – Edgar Hasty | 1995 – Terry Southerland |
| 1994 – Kenneth Groce | 1993 – Floyd York Jr. | 1992 – Adam Thompson | 1991 – Phil Houser |
| 1990 – Jimmy C. Wright | 1989 – Marion “Bud” Saul | 1988 – Charlie Blaydes | 1987 – William Hunter |
| 1986 – Harold Ward Jr. | 1985 – Howard Forbes | 1984 – David Sheward | 1983 – Oscar Blackburn |
| 1982 – Kenneth Hill | 1981 – Bill Norris | 1980 – Ray Patton | 1979 – Larry Hammond |
| 1978 – Donald Fox | 1977 – Floyd Cummings | 1976 – Robert Sheffield | 1975 – Norman E. Niles |
| 1974 – Jesse Adams | 1973 – Gary A. Marcum | 1972 – Raymond Waddell | 1971 – Harold Barton |
| 1970 – Bertie W. Ditmer | 1969 – Joe Plummer | 1968 – James Berry | 1967 – Charlie Popplewell |
| 1966 – Wilbert Rinehart | 1965 – Oscar Blackburn | 1964 – Eugene Dickerson | 1963 – Henley Burnside |
| 1962 – John W. Leveridge | 1961 – Robert E. Beeson also Cullom W. Tompkins | 1960 – Howard A. Turner | 1959 – Lawrence W. Brown |
| 1958 – William D. Teel | 1957 – John L. Keith also Wenford Donica | 1956 – Alfred M. Davidson | 1955 – Creal C. Hiatt |
| 1954 – Wilbur L. Davis | 1953 – Homer L. Sweigart | 1952 – F. Gordon Lewis | 1951 – Robert H. Richey |
| 1950 – Loring M. Cannon | 1949 – Harry McCord | 1948 – Roy E. Michelson also Otto E. Dickerson | 1947 – Jean W. Stafford |
| 1946 – Clarence R. Krumrine | 1945 – Ralph S. Carr also Karl S. Holwager | 1944 – Homer F. Smith | 1943 – Raymond Hale |
| 1942 – Roy F. Wirth | 1941 – J. Edgar Wise | 1940 – Charles W. Sorrell | 1939 – Harold D. Wantz |
| 1938 – Malcolm M. Edwards | 1937 – Clyde Vores | 1936 – Peter L. Riley | 1935 – Howard C. Martin |
| 1934 – Ambrose O. Harding | 1933 – Glenn O. Harrell | 1932 – Archie W. Franklin | 1931 – Clyde G. Hardesty |
| 1930 – Curtis W. White | 1929 – Wyatt A. Gibson | 1928 – Marcum A. Perkey | 1927 – William C. Emmert |
| 1926 – George M. Fields | 1925 – Orlando Kyser | 1924 – Isaac D. Ward | 1923 – Warren H. Converse |
| 1922 – Hugh Garrison | 1921 – Arthur G. Simmons | 1920 – Luther W. Younce | 1919 – C. N. Townsend |
| 1918 – Harmon W. Day | 1917 – Thurlow E. Richards | 1916 – Frank Hochkirch | 1915 – George K. Grant |
| 1914 – Albert D. Ogborn | 1913 – William J. Mann | 1912 – Claud VanZant | 1911 – Clifford E. Canaday |
| 1910 – William C. Bond | 1909 – Harry A. Martin | 1908 – Henry H. Stewart | 1907 – John F. McIntyre |
| 1906 – Alonzo L. Gephart | 1905 – Arlie R. Crim | 1904 – Edward Colson | 1903 – Fred Saint |
| 1902 – Frank Pence | 1901 – Robert H. McIntyre | 1900 – John R. Leonard | 1899 – Frank E. Beach |
| 1898 – George W. Maxim | 1897 – Winslow D. Jennings | 1896 – Oliver J. Gronendyke | 1895 – E. S. Ferris |
| 1894 – Charles N. Mikels* (1908-1909 Grand Master of IN) | 1893 – M. E. Forkner | 1892 – M. E. Forkner | 1891 – T. W. Millikan |
| 1890 – W. H. Elliott | 1889 – John F. Thompson | 1888 – George F. Mowrer | 1887 – George F. Mowrer |
| 1886 – John F. Thompson | 1885 – John F. Thompson | 1884 – M. T. Clawson | 1883 – T. W. Gronendyke |
| 1882 – T. W. Gronendyke | 1881 – R. M. Chambers | 1880 – R. M. Chambers | 1879 – Owen Evans |
| 1878 – Owen Evans | 1877 – Asa Hatch | 1876 – Asa Hatch | 1875 – Seth Bennett |
| 1874 – Owen Evans | 1873 – John M. Thornburg | 1872 – John M. Thornburg | 1871 – Robert M. Chambers |
| 1870 – John M. Thornburg | 1869 – John A. Holland | 1868 – John M. Thornburg | 1867 – Robert M. Chambers |
| 1866 – James J. Hamilton | 1865 – Robert M. Chambers | 1864 – William L. Brown | 1863 – Robert M. Chambers |
| 1862 – George W. Lennard | 1861 – James J. Hamilton | 1860 – Franklin Woodward | 1859 – Franklin Woodward |
| 1858 – Franklin Woodward | 1857 – George W. Lennard | 1856 – Elijah Holland | 1855 – Franklin Woodward |
| 1854 – John W. Grubbs | 1853 – Daniel Mowrer | 1852 – Daniel Mowrer | 1851 – Franklin Woodward |
| 1850 – Franklin Woodward |
